Enter your monthly spending by category to find the card that earns you the most — after annual fees.
Quick Answer
Enter your monthly spending by category to see which credit card earns the most rewards on your actual spending. The calculator ranks cards by net annual value after subtracting annual fees.
No data leaves your browser. 100% client-side.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does the effective return calculator work?
The effective return calculator takes your monthly spending in key categories (dining, groceries, gas, travel, streaming, online shopping, and everything else) and calculates each card's annual rewards value based on its category multipliers. For points cards, it factors in the points-per-dollar earn rate and the estimated cents-per-point value. It then subtracts the annual fee to show your net annual return.
What is a good effective return rate on a credit card?
A good effective return rate is 2% or higher on your total spending. Top flat-rate cards like the Citi Double Cash and Wells Fargo Active Cash earn exactly 2% on everything. By using category-specific cards strategically, you can push your effective return to 3-5% across all spending. An effective return below 1.5% means you're leaving money on the table.
Should I get a card with an annual fee?
An annual fee card is worth it only if its extra rewards exceed the fee compared to the best no-fee alternative. For example, if a $95/year card earns $300 more in rewards than a $0 card on your spending, the net benefit is $205. Use this calculator to compare: enter your spending and see whether fee cards rank higher than no-fee options after the fee is subtracted.
How are points card values calculated?
Points cards earn points-per-dollar rather than cash back. We multiply the points earned by each card's estimated cents-per-point (cpp) value. For example, Chase Sapphire Preferred earns 3x on dining; at 2.0 cpp, that's effectively 6% back on dining when points are transferred to travel partners. Cash back cards use a 1:1 ratio (1% back = 1 cent per dollar).
What spending categories matter most for credit card rewards?
Dining and groceries are typically the highest-impact categories because most households spend $300-800/month on each. Gas ($100-300/month) and travel are next. Many premium cards offer 3-6x on dining and groceries, making these categories the biggest differentiators between cards. The 'other' catch-all category also matters since it often represents 40-60% of total spending.
How much cash back can I earn per year?
On $30,000 in annual spending, a flat 2% card earns $600/year. A strategic multi-card setup targeting 3-5% in top categories can earn $900-1,500/year on the same spending. High spenders ($50,000+/year) with premium travel cards and optimized category multipliers can exceed $2,000 in annual rewards value.
What is the best credit card for overall spending?
For a single card, the Wells Fargo Active Cash or Citi Double Cash (both 2% flat) are the best for most people. For heavy dining spenders, the Amex Gold (4x dining at ~2cpp = 8% effective) or Chase Sapphire Preferred (3x at ~2cpp = 6% effective) deliver more value despite annual fees. Enter your actual spending above to find your personal best card.
Does this calculator account for signup bonuses?
No. This calculator focuses on ongoing annual rewards from regular spending. Signup bonuses (like 60,000 points for spending $4,000 in 3 months) provide a one-time boost that can significantly increase first-year value. For most cards, the signup bonus is worth $500-1,000, which should be factored into your first-year decision separately.
Methodology: Earn rates are based on each card's published category multipliers as of Mar 2026.
Points cards use estimated cents-per-point (cpp) values from industry-standard valuations — Chase UR at 2.0cpp,
Amex MR at 2.0cpp, Capital One miles at 1.0cpp. Cash back cards use 1:1 valuation.
Net annual value = gross rewards minus annual fee. Results are estimates for comparison purposes only.